Fight back.
Mark Towner rarely comes up with any original content on his site, meaning he copies wholesale from other sources, but when he does can you say "lawsuit"?
He plans to sue another local blogger, Jesse Harris for "slander"(Does he mean libel?). Jesse isn't taking this sitting down, and plans to fight back.
Is it any wonder that Towner has garnered so many enemies, both liberal and conservative?
Wednesday, June 27, 2007
When Local Bloggers Attack...
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
4:58 PM
3
comments
Labels: best and worst, blog, lawsuit
Wednesday, June 13, 2007
Voucher Supporters: Court Ruling Could Have Been Worse
Freshman Legislator, Kay McIff(R) isn't off to the most conservative start at the Utah House of Representatives. McIff is lockstep with another Republican of questionable conservative credentials, Sheryl Allen, and ranks under the top three most conservative Democrats.
Before I'm accused of breaking the eleventh commandment, I'll take a divergent course and talk about vouchers and which tactics are intellectually honest. McIff had suggested, before the Supreme Court offered clarification, that the legislature ought to take care of the voucher issue by forgetting that they ever had passed an amendment.
Reasonable people, have, and will disagree about this idea. The ultimate result of the court decision accomplished nearly what McIff had suggested. I say nearly, because the amendment comes back if the voters support the primary voucher law in November. Under McIff's proposal it would not. But, the court's motives and purpose were also different than McIff and his cohorts. The court argued that the amendment could not stand alone due to a question of process, not a question of outcome. The Supreme Court did not, or should not, care whether or not vouchers are ultimately passed. The court ought not to consider whether the law is nice, but only whether it is constitutional.
McIff, it appears, had a different idea about why the second amendment bill should be eliminated. His reason, it seems clear, was to make the voucher law a better target for those who wish to kill it.
I have two reasons that support the above assertion. One, the amendment bill was passed to satisfy the demands of those now opposed to the voucher law. (Suddenly they want to get rid of it?) Two, under McIff's plan, the voucher law would have been less palatable then it is now under the courts ruling. McIff is openly opposed to the voucher law, and wants its repeal.
So, despite what some might say, the supreme court decision was not a clear win for voucher opponents. The next battle will be decided, very clearly, at the ballot box in November.
Note: I have previously praised McIff for taking the high road, and I'm open to the possibility of praising him once again.
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
10:44 AM
5
comments
Friday, June 08, 2007
Clarity (From Me) On Vouchers
Let me make my feelings clear on the courts voucher ruling.
- The Utah Supreme Court was right to rule in the way that they did, although I favor vouchers.
- The Supreme Court ought to be originalist in their reading of the law, not activist.
- The Governor showed no spine in pushing the decision on the wrong branch of government. (The right branch would be the Legislature)
- Blame for the voucher law confusion falls upon the heads of the legislature, not those that produced the referendum. Initiative, or referendum, do not a clear, or murky, law make.
- As many as can vote should vote in November.
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
11:27 PM
5
comments
Labels: lawsuit, legislature
Judical Activism: Who is Earl Christensen?
- He has clients who initiated the voucher referendum process.
- He spoke to the Utah Supreme Court as a 'party of interest'.
- He wanted the Court to be Activist by changing the ballot language when two Justices said the Court had no authority to do so.
- He said, "I don't think that the Legislature is the appropriate place to correct this".
Listen and decide, but he doesn't sound pro-voucher to me.
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
11:04 PM
0
comments
Labels: lawsuit, weasel words
Utah Supreme Court Dismisses Judicial Activism Request
Please take careful note of this exchange between Mr. Christenson, and Justice Wilkins. (My apologies on my spelling, I transcribed this myself).
Justice Wilkins: "Mister Christenson, the difficulty that we face, obviously, is that the ballot title statute limits our legal authority to modify ballot title to 'patent falsehood, or bias'. Is there something about the ballot title that is either 'patently false, or biased'?"The Justice is right that it is not the courts place to legislate. Of course, the court has subsequently found that HB 174 does not stand on its own. Go here to listen to the whole exchange yourself.
Christenson: "I do understand that limitation, but I think this case is so unique, and so unusual, that to simply submit the form of 148 to the voters without their knowing the effect of their vote--that of course could come later in a subsequent proceeding-- but, it will chill the enthusiasm for people involved in this vital issue. It will probably limit the voter out turn, and I think this court has the power. It's been given this task by the legislature. This court has the power to say that under these very unusual circumstances--uh, I have not seen a case like this--"
Justice: "Uh, we have! Not..not with this many folks. But, everyone that comes to us with a ballot title concern feels just as vitally concerned as you and your folks do. And, um, the legislature has given us authority by statute to address it, but they have severely limited that authority, and if you want us to do something that's outside that authority you better help us find a way to do it!"
I agree with the court that the legislature has created this mess by not being clear in the two bills. The Governor should have jumped in and called a special session for the purpose of clearing the air.
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
5:01 PM
4
comments
Labels: lawsuit, legislature
Tuesday, June 05, 2007
Keeping Tabs On Vouchers
How many of you are reeling, as I am, from the slings and arrows cast in the last week on the voucher imbroglio?
This is the problem with the 24 hour news cycle. There is often no time to sort things out. Well, consider this moment, an eddy on the river of the news from which you can rest your paddles, and long for the days of yore when the news blackened your fingers instead of your thoughts.
The Players
- Steve Urquhart -- Legislator, Attorney, and Sponsor of the Voucher Bills/Laws
- Kim Burningham --Not only the Chairman of the State School Board, but a founding member of Utahns for Public Schools. Burningham presided over the board on a controversial decision to hold the Voucher law implementation until answers could be given to the board.
- Parents For Choice in Education--Non-profit, funded from outside of Utah, but founded by two Utah entrepreneurs, and heavy contributer to the campaigns of voucher supporters. Most notably, Kim Burningham's opponent in this last election. Clearly, if they are conspiring, they were not very good at ousting the entrenched Burningham, although they have waxed the proverbial floor with others.
- Utah Supreme Court (less Chief Justice Christine Durham) will hear arguments from both sides on June 8th.
- Democratic Legislature--A group unanimously opposed, not only to vouchers, but to those who promote them.
- The Senate Site--Not the
Republicansmajority caucus-proper, but the anonymous version of the same. Supporters of all things voucher. - Mark Shurtleff --Attorney General of Utah, and advisor to the State School Board and Governors Office. The A.G. has advised the State School Board to implement HB.174.
2/12/2007: HB148-Voucher Bill narrowly passed by one vote, exposing it to the threat of a referendum, is signed by the Governor.
3/6/07 : HB174-Bill intended to "fix" the first voucher bill passes by a much larger margin, 2/3rds majority, and signed into law making it "referendum-proof".
4/30/07: Voucher Referendum Certified by the Lt. Governor
5/15/07: Ballot language written and mailed to the Lt. Governor. Language has HB148 in the title.
Summary
Before you ask, I can't say that Governor Huntsman is a player, although he's jumped in and out on this issue. He just hasn't demonstrated strong leadership, one way or another. He doesn't seem to like to play 'hot potato'. Neither am I trying to be predictive about if, or when we do get to vote on this, or another bill. It seems that we might have a special session to clarify, and we might just leave this for the courts to sort out.
Update: My apologies. I neglected to mention Mark Shurtleff as a player in the voucher dispute. Although this list was never intended to be comprehensive, it was to include the 'major' players. For the same reason that I leave off the Governor, I must remember to include the A.G. Shurtleff has been a stand up guy in all of this. Giving his views, and sticking by them. Some will call him 'arrogant' for this, but he is taking a legal viewpoint, which is his job. The news today reveals that he has fired two Attorneys for misrepresenting the view of the Attorney Generals Office, and giving contrary advice.
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
1:38 PM
6
comments
Labels: education, lawsuit, legislature
Monday, May 21, 2007
State School Board: Above The Law?
Lately, I get indignant about very few things, but this weekend I saw something that was maddening.
First, some background. The State Board has refused to implement the voucher law until their twenty questions are answered by the Attorney General. Kim Burningham, the Chairman of the State School Board was on with Rod Decker saying how surprised he was that the School Board had not been sued to prevent them from implementing vouchers before the deadline. I could see that it would have been politically advantages for Burningham to have the board be the target of a lawsuit. Then it would be easy for him to say, 'we can't implement vouchers until the courts give us permission'. The fact is that nobody sued, and now Burningham is trying to justify not following the law.
Burningham appears to be getting away with it.
Mr. Burningham, oppose vouchers if you will. Speak publicly against them. Devote your political clout to their ultimate demise, but follow the law! Just follow the law!
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
1:57 PM
8
comments
Wednesday, May 16, 2007
Bountiful Dump: Non-residents Keep-Out
I was over at my sister's this weekend lamenting the fact that non-Bountiful Residents cannot enter the Bountiful Dump. We had to call my brother to drive in a truckload. I did a little research into this apparent absurdity only to conclude that it is perfectly correct that I am required to show that I am a Bountiful Resident before dumping there.
If you're wondering, the dump is owned and operated by Bountiful, not the County. Residents of the County may dump their junk in Layton. Bountiful opted out of participation in the 'Service District' in 1984 and even participated in a legal battle concerning some fees imposed that went up to the Utah Supreme Court.
As an aside, there appears to be a vibrant bird watching community that hovers about the dump. I wonder if those Legacy highway detractors knew about that?
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
1:02 PM
0
comments
Tuesday, March 06, 2007
Rulon Vs NSL
Want to see an Olympian in person? Then you might consider attending the March 20th meeting of the North Salt Lake City Council. Rulon Gardner, former Greco-Roman Wrestler, will be addressing the city council to ask for some money to help rebuild a wall that he says was poorly constructed by a previous owner, and should not have passed inspection.
His lawyer says that there will be no lawsuit against the city since the law makes municipalities immune from lawsuits related to negligent inspections.
You might recognize Rulon's lawyer too, if you follow politics in Utah. He is none other than Todd Weiler, Chairman of the Republican Party in Davis County, and newly elected Vice-Chair of the State GOP. Some think Weiler may have a Governorship in his future. That is if, as is alleged here, that Weiler is actually a patsy of the UEA. Weiler, of course, denies this anonymous allegation.
I just thought some of you might be interested in seeing the parade of who's who, and who was who, in Davis County. Right here in little-old NSL.
Hat tip: Clipper
Second hat tip: Political Spyglass
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
9:10 PM
3
comments
Wednesday, February 21, 2007
Clippertoday: NSL Did Well In 'David and Goliath' Tilt
Rolf Koecher, with whom I've formerly butted heads, has written a good piece summarizing the 80 acres land dispute that pitted NSL (a.k.a. David) against its much larger neighbor SLC (a.k.a. Goliath).
Read it here.
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
1:37 PM
0
comments
Labels: land, lawsuit, legislature
Friday, February 16, 2007
80 Acres Settlement
Now this is more like it!
NSL is expected to chime-in today on an agreement between it and SLC that would have SL buying much of NSL's land at $3.5 million dollars. That's much better than the earlier threat of buying a small percentage of the land at several thousand dollars.
SB130 will probably now be irrelevant.
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
12:05 PM
0
comments
Labels: land, lawsuit, legislature
Friday, February 02, 2007
SB130 Passes Muster In Committee
SB130, which would allow NSL to annex its 80 acres of land without permission from SLC just received a favorable recommendation from the committee. Now, it's on to the Senate floor.
I've spoken of this bill at the links below.
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
3:07 PM
2
comments
Labels: land, lawsuit, legislature
Thursday, February 01, 2007
Desnews:Bill to allow N. Salt Lake to annex 80 acres held in the Senate
A recent Deseret News article leads me to believe that the municipal lands bill in the Senate, that would give a pass to NSL annexing its 80 acres of land, may fail in committee.
It sounds like the legislature doesn't want to get involved in the suit. The question is this, is SLC going to want to settle out of court with NSL anyway?
Update: The article was wrong. It passed committee.
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
2:50 PM
0
comments
Labels: land, lawsuit, legislature
SB0130:Municipal Code Amendments (D. Eastman)
The Senate Government Operations and Political Subdivisions Standing Committee will consider a bill that would make certain disputes, like the 80 acre land annexation lawsuit between NSL and SL, moot. Cities would be able to annex land that falls within the boundaries of neighboring cities if certain conditions are met.
DATE: Friday, February 2, 2007
TIME: 2:00 PM
PLACE: Room W020, West Office Building, State Capitol Complex
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
12:12 PM
0
comments
Labels: announcements, land, lawsuit, legislature
Monday, January 29, 2007
NSL V. SL V. State Senate
North Salt Lake City and Salt Lake City may settle out of court in regards to the land dispute that has occupied both cities.
80 acres of NSL owned property lies within SL boundaries. NSL would like to annex the land in order to partially develop it. SL and NSL sued each other over the land. State Senator Dan Eastman has introduced a bill, SB0130, that would make it possible for a city to annex land that is adjacent to it, but not within its boundaries without having to ask permission from the neighboring city.
Has Salt Lake City seen Eastman's bill, a threat to their position, as likely to invalidate their lawsuit? I can't see any other reason that the big gorilla neighbor to our south would be willing to negotiate now.
Desnews: Can Cities Stave off Court Fight?
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
9:42 AM
0
comments
Labels: land, lawsuit, legislature
Tuesday, January 09, 2007
Davis School District| Never Ending Protests
Walk with me over the time line of events we've witnessed in regards to the Davis School District boundary debacle.
November
Lawsuit leveled by a group of Bountiful parents comes to a head as the District abandons its boundary plans and goes with a consultant.
January
A plan is presented, not much different from the first, that leads to 600 letters from critics. Groups that are publicly opposed to the plan hark from Syracuse, Layton, and Cherry Lane. The Bountiful Parents remain critical.
Things do not look good for the District. If the numerous protests are simply ignored as the board votes in the proposed boundaries, will we have another lawsuit? If the board accepts the criticisms that have been voiced, will we go back to the drawing board again?
This is why this boundary dispute is all the rage.
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
4:56 PM
2
comments
Labels: education, lawsuit, transparency, waste
Monday, January 08, 2007
Utah to file suit over Jordan's closed meetings
The Attorney's General office is now taking the Jordan School District to court over Open Meetings violations. The irony here is that when Davis County got in trouble over their violations, Jordan District was touted as the ideal district in that regard.
Utah to file suit over Jordan's closed meetings
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
10:53 AM
0
comments
Labels: education, lawsuit, transparency
Friday, January 05, 2007
Boundary Dispute Redux
More on the School Boundary dispute. Both from those opponents to the plan and the School District.
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
7:51 AM
0
comments
Tuesday, January 02, 2007
Consultant to Offer New Plan
I have nothing new to add to this debate. Let's see what the 'consultant' has figured out.
Wednesday, 5:30 PM, Layton High School
Davis School District to Get New Boundary Plan
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
9:06 AM
0
comments
Labels: announcements, education, lawsuit
Wednesday, December 20, 2006
Boundary change announcement afoot
The consultant hired to revisit the Davis School Districts boundary changes may be weeks away from a proposal.
Davis school boundary decision may be near
Posted by
Tyler Farrer
at
1:25 PM
0
comments
Labels: citizenship, education, lawsuit, waste

